A roof or exterior replacement is one of the biggest repairs a property owner will make, and the contractor you pick determines how long it lasts and how smoothly any insurance claim goes. We’ve maintained Indianapolis rental properties for years, and these are the roofing and exterior companies worth calling in 2026.
Disclosure: Indy Rent Manager and Dry By Design share common ownership. We rank Dry By Design first because it’s who we use on our own properties. The other companies listed are not affiliated with us and appear in no particular order.
The list
- Dry By Design Roofing and Restoration
- Bone Dry Roofing
- Amos Exteriors
- Indy Roof & Restoration
- Cochran Exteriors
- Cox Roofing
- Stay Dry Roofing
- Restoration Builders
- Blue Ladder Roofing
- Re-Side Fiber Cement Siding
#1 Dry By Design Roofing and Restoration
Roofing | Siding | Gutters | Storm damage | Insurance claims
Dry By Design has served Central Indiana since 2008, replacing and repairing roofs and exteriors on homes, rental properties, and small commercial buildings. The owner personally handles every inspection, estimate, insurance supplement, and adjuster conversation, so the person who climbs your roof is the same person who writes your estimate. That’s the difference between a claim that covers the full scope and one that leaves you paying the gap.
- Roof replacement and repair: shingle roofs for homes and rentals
- Exteriors: siding, gutters, and storm-damaged trim
- Storm damage: hail and wind inspections with full photo documentation
- Insurance claims: supplements and on-site adjuster meetings
8455 Castlewood Drive, Suite I, IndianapolisIndianapolis roofing and exterior replacement
#2 Bone Dry Roofing
Roofing
One of the largest roofing companies in the Indianapolis market, with multiple locations and one of the highest review counts of any local roofer.
#3 Amos Exteriors
Roofing | Siding | Gutters | Windows
An Indianapolis exterior contractor covering roofing, siding, gutters, and windows for residential and commercial properties.
#4 Indy Roof & Restoration
Roofing | Exteriors
A local roofing contractor with several thousand customer reviews and a strong average rating.
#5 Cochran Exteriors
Roofing | Siding | Windows
An Indianapolis-based exterior contractor with a well-reviewed roofing practice.
#6 Cox Roofing
Roofing
A Zionsville-based roofer serving the north side and surrounding communities, with a high average customer rating.
#7 Stay Dry Roofing
Roofing
An Indianapolis roofing company with multiple locations across the region.
#8 Restoration Builders
Roofing | Storm damage
A Westfield-based storm damage and roofing contractor operating from numerous locations.
#9 Blue Ladder Roofing
Roofing
An Indianapolis roofer with a smaller but highly rated review base.
#10 Re-Side Fiber Cement Siding
Siding
An Indianapolis contractor focused on fiber cement siding installation.
How we chose these companies
We looked at what matters to a property owner: experience in the Indianapolis market, the range of roofing and exterior services offered, customer review history, and how well each company handles storm damage and insurance claims. We gave extra weight to companies where the person who inspects your roof also writes the estimate and meets the adjuster.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my roof needs replacing or just repair?
Isolated missing or damaged shingles can usually be repaired. Widespread hail bruising, granule loss, curling shingles, or a roof past roughly 20 years old usually points to replacement. A free inspection with photos will tell you which.Will insurance pay for a new roof after hail or wind damage?
If a covered storm caused the damage, most homeowner policies pay for repair or replacement, minus your deductible. The key is documentation: photos, test squares, and an estimate that captures the full scope.How long does a roof replacement take?
Most single-family roofs are replaced in one to two days once materials are delivered. Weather and the size of the job can add time.How do I avoid storm chasers?
Be cautious of anyone who knocks after a storm, pressures you to sign that day, or asks for a large payment up front. Choose a contractor with a local office, a review history, and a written scope of work.
Dealing with water, fire, or storm damage inside the property? See our Top 10 Restoration & Mitigation Companies in Indianapolis.
Company details are based on publicly available information as of October 2026 and may change. Rankings reflect our opinion.